Services

All servicesBookkeeping & QuickBooks OnlineOutsourced CFOTax planning & preparationQuickBooks cleanup

Who it's for

Contractors & tradesReal estate ownersProfessional practicesRestaurants & hospitality

Guides

Tax strategyEnrolled Agent vs CPAS-corp vs LLC in CaliforniaCost segregation

Practice

AboutContact Schedule a call

Entity Structure · California

S-Corp vs LLC in California: when each one wins.

A lot of entity advice skips the state. The $800 minimum, the LLC fee schedule, the 1.5% S-Corp franchise tax, from an Enrolled Agent’s perspective.

The Federal View

What “LLC” and “S-Corp” actually mean.

An LLC is a legal entity created at the state level. Its tax treatment is flexible: by default, a single-member LLC is taxed as a sole proprietorship (Schedule C on your personal return), and a multi-member LLC is taxed as a partnership (Form 1065 and K-1s to the members). The legal structure protects personal assets from business liabilities; the tax treatment doesn’t change much from operating without an entity.

An S-Corp is not a separate legal entity. It’s a tax election. You can take an existing LLC or a state-formed corporation and elect S-Corp tax treatment by filing Form 2553 with the IRS. The election changes how the business is taxed: profits flow through to the owner’s personal return (no double taxation), and crucially, only the W-2 portion of the owner’s compensation is subject to self-employment / FICA tax. The rest of the profit is distributed free of self-employment tax.

That payroll-tax saving is the main reason owners elect S-Corp status. It’s also why the IRS looks closely at what S-Corp owners pay themselves.

The California Overlay

Three things California does that the rest of the country doesn’t.

01

The $800 minimum franchise tax

Every LLC, S-Corp, and corporation operating in California generally pays at least $800 to the Franchise Tax Board every year, whether the business made $1 or $1 million. (A sole proprietor with no entity pays $0.) The entity-vs-no-entity decision starts here.

02

The California LLC fee

LLCs taxed as partnerships or sole props pay an additional fee tied to gross receipts (see schedule below). This fee disappears when the LLC elects S-Corp tax treatment, replaced by the 1.5% S-Corp franchise tax.

03

The 1.5% S-Corp tax

S-Corps in California pay 1.5% of net California income to the FTB, with an $800 minimum. So an S-Corp with $400K of net income pays approximately $6,000 in California S-Corp tax. Federal S-Corp pass-through tax is zero, but California is not zero.

Total California incomeLLC fee
Less than $250,000 in CA income$0
$250,000 – $499,999$900
$500,000 – $999,999$2,500
$1,000,000 – $4,999,999$6,000
$5,000,000 or more$11,790

When to Elect

When the S-Corp election makes sense.

  • Net business income above roughly $60K–$80Kafter reasonable compensation, as a rule of thumb. Below that, the FICA savings don’t cover the compliance overhead.
  • You’re a service businesswhere most of the income is earned by your labor. Consultants, contractors, professional practices, online businesses.
  • You can sustain the compliance overhead.Payroll, separate Form 1120-S, reasonable-comp documentation, accountable plan. Roughly $2K–$4K/year more than running as an LLC.
  • Your income is relatively stable.S-Corps work best when the owner’s W-2 salary can be set in January and run consistently.

When to Stay an LLC

When staying an LLC is the right call.

  • Net income below roughly $60K–$80K.Compliance cost eats the FICA savings.
  • Real estate holding entities.S-Corps and real estate don’t mix, built-in gains, distribution-of-appreciated-property rules, and basis limitations bite at the worst times. Keep rentals in an LLC.
  • Investment partnerships.When the entity holds passive investments, LLC-as-partnership is almost always right.
  • Multi-member businesses with very different ownership splits.S-Corps have rigid rules: one class of stock, distributions strictly pro-rata to ownership.
  • Businesses planning a VC or institutional funding round.S-Corps can’t have corporate or partnership shareholders. C-Corp or LLC is the right vehicle.

Reasonable Comp

Why the S-Corp election fails most often.

The IRS doesn’t care if you elect S-Corp status. It cares that you pay yourself a “reasonable” W-2 salary. The whole point of the election is that profits above your salary aren’t subject to FICA, so owners are incentivized to set the salary low. The IRS knows this and can reclassify an underpaid owner’s distributions as wages, with payroll tax, penalties, and interest.

“Reasonable” depends on what someone in your role would earn doing the same work at a different company. A common rule of thumb, not an IRS rule: 30–50% of net income for service businesses, scaled down somewhat for capital-intensive businesses. The IRS publishes guidance but no safe-harbor numbers.

I commission third-party reasonable-comp studies for clients with $250K+ of net income. For smaller businesses, I document the comp number against industry data, the owner’s role, hours, and credentials. The point isn’t the lowest defensible number. It’s a number that, if questioned, has a clean answer in the file.

Frequently Asked

Common California S-Corp vs LLC questions.

I have an LLC and want to elect S-Corp status. Do I form a new entity?

No. File Form 2553 with the IRS to elect S-Corp tax treatment on the existing LLC. The state-level entity stays the same; only the tax treatment changes.

I missed the Form 2553 deadline for this year. What now?

Relief for a late S-Corp election is available under Rev. Proc. 2013-30 if there’s reasonable cause and the election is filed within 3 years and 75 days of the intended effective date.

I run a real estate rental in an LLC. Should I elect S-Corp?

Almost certainly no. Real estate inside an S-Corp creates built-in-gains issues, distribution-of-appreciated-property problems, and basis limitations. Keep rentals in an LLC.

My CPA says I should elect S-Corp because I’m making $90K. Is that right?

Maybe. At $90K of net income the payroll-tax saving can be a few thousand dollars a year, before the added cost of payroll and a separate return. I model this on a per-client basis.

Does electing S-Corp change my California taxes?

Yes. You pay 1.5% of California net income (at least $800) as S-Corp franchise tax, but you stop paying the California LLC fee. At higher revenue levels the math gets close, the federal saving is usually larger than the state cost, but it’s worth modeling specifically.

I’ve been told to use the “60/40 rule” for S-Corp comp. Is that safe?

That’s industry shorthand, not an IRS rule. There’s no safe harbor. “Reasonable” is fact-specific. A return defended in audit is one with documentation, not one with a rule of thumb.

The strategies and figures on this page are general information, not tax advice for a specific situation. Limits, rates, and rules change. Confirm current rules and numbers before acting.

Model your specific S-Corp vs LLC math.

Tell me what you need help with. The first call is just to see what's involved and whether it's a good fit.

Schedule a consultation

info@convenientaccounting.com · (805) 393-1162 · Santa Barbara, California