The IRS doesn’t care if you elect S-Corp status. It cares that you pay yourself a “reasonable” W-2 salary. The whole point of the election is that profits above your salary aren’t subject to FICA, so owners are incentivized to set the salary low. The IRS knows this and can reclassify an underpaid owner’s distributions as wages, with payroll tax, penalties, and interest.
“Reasonable” depends on what someone in your role would earn doing the same work at a different company. A common rule of thumb, not an IRS rule: 30–50% of net income for service businesses, scaled down somewhat for capital-intensive businesses. The IRS publishes guidance but no safe-harbor numbers.
I commission third-party reasonable-comp studies for clients with $250K+ of net income. For smaller businesses, I document the comp number against industry data, the owner’s role, hours, and credentials. The point isn’t the lowest defensible number. It’s a number that, if questioned, has a clean answer in the file.